.png?20250828091023405+1000)
Pudding is one of those foods that gets people talking. It could be the flavourful taste, or maybe it reminds everyone of family get-togethers, but somehow this simple dessert always brings people together. When you start preparing it, everyone has a preference. Some people love steamed pudding because it's soft, while others like boiling it the old-fashioned way, and plenty of people prefer baking it for the crispy edges. Each way of cooking it is special and has its own story. In this article, we're going to check out the different ways to prepare pudding, from old methods to some new ones—like how to prepare a vegan Christmas pudding.
Surprisingly, the same ingredient list can give you dramatically different results depending on whether you steam, boil, or bake. A suet-rich batter steamed low and slow will set into a tender, velvety sponge; boiled versions skew denser and slightly firmer; baked versions lean toward cake territory with caramelised edges and a lighter crumb—especially once sauce meets sponge. Those distinctions, which show up in home kitchens and pro pastry shops alike, are the secret to cooking the pudding you actually want to eat.
From an American perspective, “pudding” conjures a silky custard; from a British one, it often means “dessert” broadly, encompassing steamed, boiled, and baked classics from spotted dick to sticky toffee. That linguistic split sets up mismatched expectations—someone anticipating crème-cup smoothness might be startled by a celebratory cannonball of fruit, spice, and suet. Understanding the word helps you choose the right method and recipe.
-3.png)
Before thermostatic ovens and nonstick tins, steaming and boiling were simply practical: you tied a batter in a cloth or set it in a basin, then cooked it in a pot over the hearth. Those humble techniques birthed the predecessors of modern Christmas pudding, evolving from medieval “plum pottage” (think meaty broth with dried fruits) into the booze-laced suet dessert that Victorians canonised and we still flambé.
Under the lid of a softly simmering pot, steam circulates evenly around a lidded basin, coaxing a smooth crumb without toughening the batter. Because there’s no harsh direct heat, custard-leaning puddings and low-flour batters shine here, remaining tender rather than rubbery. If you’re chasing that classic British sponge—moist, sliceable, and receptive to rivers of custard—steaming is your north star.
In the oldest kitchens, batter met boiling water via a sturdy pudding cloth or a basin immersed in the pot, and hours later emerged dark, sticky, and gloriously rich. That complete contact with liquid creates a sturdier set and a more concentrated, almost fudgy character—especially in dried-fruit-heavy recipes that are rested and fed with alcohol. If your holidays revolve around a cannonball you can set alight, you’re probably team “boiled.”
For everyday kitchens, the oven’s consistency is hard to beat. Baked versions—think bread-and-butter pudding, self-saucing varieties, and the many modern takes on sticky date—develop delicate browning and a slightly lighter crumb. Texture leans cake-ward but remains moist, particularly when paired with toffee or custard. Busy cooks and small apartments tend to drift toward the bake—it’s equipment-light and scalable.
.png)
Start with your texture target. If you want a plush sponge that slices cleanly yet melts under hot custard, go steamed. When you crave a compact, intensely flavoured sphere with a firm bite (and a showy flambé), go boiled. If you love a lightly caramelised top with a cake-like crumb, bake it. Then match your kitchen reality—stockpot and space for a trivet? Go steam/boil. Only an oven on a weeknight? Bake and don’t look back.
On most stoves, a deep pot with a tight lid, a trivet or inverted saucer, and a heatproof basin with a foil or parchment cap will steam a pudding just fine. For boiling, you’ll add a string-tied cloth technique or fully immerse a lidded basin, watching your water levels. For baking, any sturdy tin or ramekin set will do. Pressure cookers and Instant Pots can simulate steaming in a fraction of the time, though you may need to tinker to avoid over-hydration.
At heart, these methods juggle three variables—temperature, hydration, and time. Steaming surrounds the batter at ~100°C with saturated vapour, limiting crust formation and preserving moisture; boiling adds hydrostatic pressure and more direct wet contact; baking climbs higher and drier, creating Maillard notes and gentle crust. Flour and eggs provide structure; suet or butter supplies tenderness; dried fruits sip up liquid and swell, enriching mouthfeel.
Interestingly, many heritage recipes flex across techniques with minor tweaks. Increase liquid slightly for baking to prevent dryness; reduce flour a touch for steaming so the crumb stays delicate; watch salt and sugar in boiled versions because evaporation concentrates flavours. A good baseline: a rich batter (fat + eggs), dried fruit, warm spice, and a bittersweet element (molasses or treacle) to deepen colour.
Come late November, the custom of Stir-up Sunday brings families to the bowl to stir clockwise for luck, make a wish, and tuck silver charms into the batter. Weeks later, a brandy-fueled blaze announces dessert, blue flames licking around the basin as everyone leans back to cheer. Ritual, more than any single spice, is why traditional christmas pudding still shows up—even after decades of trend fatigue and supermarket shortcuts.
Suet (beef or vegetable) creates that signature plushness by melting into layers; butter brings dairy sweetness but a slightly different crumb. Treacle or molasses darkens and bitters the mix; fresh citrus zest brightens, and a glug of stout or IPA adds backbone, especially in fruit-heavy recipes. Above all, dried fruits respond to technique: steaming swells them juicier; baking caramelises their edges; boiling infuses them through the batter.
Should your steamed pudding emerge soggy, suspect a loose lid or too-vigorous boil forcing water into the basin—dry it in a low oven and adjust next time. If a baked pudding feels dry, drown it (kindly) in hot sauce and shorten the bake in future. When a boiled cloth pudding sticks, switch to a better-buttered cloth and ensure a good flour dusting. Pressure cooker failures usually involve too much liquid or not enough stand time after cooking.
Even traditionalists swap in vegetable suet for dietary reasons and lighten the mix with grated apple or carrot. For dairy-free or egg-light batters, steaming is forgiving because gentle heat protects structure without demanding lots of flour. Sugar can often be reduced by 10–15% in fruit-heavy mixes; spices, citrus, and booze carry more than their weight in flavour. Historical recipes were pragmatic; yours can be too.
In the end, the “best” method is the one that delivers the texture you love, fits your schedule, and honours your rituals. Steam when tenderness matters; boil when ceremony and depth call the shots; bake when convenience and caramel sing louder. And if your December table needs a plant-forward showstopper, try a date-rich, citrus-bright vegan Christmas pudding that steams gently to a glossy, celebratory slice—then serve it with brandy-free custard or a dairy-free complex sauce so everyone gets a fork in the fun.
Because the method shapes more than doneness—shaping memory, mood, and meaning—treat it like a seasoning you choose with intent. Pick your technique first, adapt your batter second, and you’ll end up with a pudding that tastes exactly like what you pictured. If you’d like, I can: draft a one-page cheat sheet for all three methods; convert your favourite family recipe across steaming, boiling, and baking; or sketch a tidy holiday prep calendar so the big day feels easy.
.png?20250828091023556+1000)
